User talk:Eatwithspoons: Difference between revisions
PWpedia>Mentallaxative m question |
PWpedia>Vitenks No edit summary |
||
| Line 15: | Line 15: | ||
Since you seem to be on now, I'll ask you a few things. How much exactly are we allowed to modify other people's guides here? I get the feeling that these guides 'belong' to their writers and we aren't allowed to change them too much. (Other wikis have a rule that you can't sign on the page itself or write the article from a first person perspective, to give the impression it's not owned by anyone.) Some guides overlap in content; are we allowed to cut out the 'good' part of one guide, make it into a separate page, and remove all its duplicates? (I am thinking of the wizard guides when posing this question.) --[[User:Mentallaxative|Ljia]] 18:17, 1 September 2009 (UTC) | Since you seem to be on now, I'll ask you a few things. How much exactly are we allowed to modify other people's guides here? I get the feeling that these guides 'belong' to their writers and we aren't allowed to change them too much. (Other wikis have a rule that you can't sign on the page itself or write the article from a first person perspective, to give the impression it's not owned by anyone.) Some guides overlap in content; are we allowed to cut out the 'good' part of one guide, make it into a separate page, and remove all its duplicates? (I am thinking of the wizard guides when posing this question.) --[[User:Mentallaxative|Ljia]] 18:17, 1 September 2009 (UTC) | ||
== Guides == | |||
How are we going to categorise guides? The current 'big fat warning' doesn't seem very polite, but on the other hand you don't want new players sent away with lies. | |||
The problem is that a guide is at least 80% opinion, which is kinda hard to merge together. | |||
And on a side note: Rare pets. Can we please just delete 90% of these guides? They're identical, just copy and pasted from ecatomb. --[[User:Vitenks|Vitenka]] (There's one named [[Click Here]] for goodness sakes, that at least needs a rename) | |||
Revision as of 07:59, 3 September 2009
Oh hai, this are mai talk page
How do i make Tables. im getting really confused cause the first part of the guide seems to be
cut off. (this is for my jewlcrafting guilde =(. --Exploreralpha HuntressPrime/Lost city
- check this link out http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Help:Table
I hope i'm adding this right, how do I post another similar guide such as quest guides? The rule says to create another page and link to section page....which part is the Section page? Thx. --Peppermintgloss 01:37, 1 August 2009 (UTC)
i have a semi guide in the works. regarding FB drops and Practices. may i still post this even though its not complete. (i hope to get others opinions and facts on the matter xD) --Exploreralpha 11:23, 1 August 2009 (UTC)HuntressPrime/Lost city
Question
Since you seem to be on now, I'll ask you a few things. How much exactly are we allowed to modify other people's guides here? I get the feeling that these guides 'belong' to their writers and we aren't allowed to change them too much. (Other wikis have a rule that you can't sign on the page itself or write the article from a first person perspective, to give the impression it's not owned by anyone.) Some guides overlap in content; are we allowed to cut out the 'good' part of one guide, make it into a separate page, and remove all its duplicates? (I am thinking of the wizard guides when posing this question.) --Ljia 18:17, 1 September 2009 (UTC)
Guides
How are we going to categorise guides? The current 'big fat warning' doesn't seem very polite, but on the other hand you don't want new players sent away with lies.
The problem is that a guide is at least 80% opinion, which is kinda hard to merge together.
And on a side note: Rare pets. Can we please just delete 90% of these guides? They're identical, just copy and pasted from ecatomb. --Vitenka (There's one named Click Here for goodness sakes, that at least needs a rename)
