User talk:Kyrrel

Guild Directories

The various guild directory articles on the wiki all conform to the same standard, so please do not change that without any discussion. If you think that there is a better standard format, then it should be applied to all of the "Guild Directory" articles. For example, you added "Server:", with nothing after it, all over the "Heaven's Tear Guild Directory" article. There is no good reason for that change, since all of the entries on that page will be on the Heaven's Tear server. I reverted that change and the ones after it. If you think the guild directory format should be changed, please justify it on the article's talk page and we can discuss those format changes. Thank you. -- Sangodoc - PWI wiki mod (talk) 08:06, 8 November 2010 (UTC)

First of all, it is not my job to keep track of every faction that is listed on those pages on every server. I don't know where you got the impression that that was my job, but that is false.

Second of all, if you have evidence that those factions are not in existence, changed leaders, or are listed incorrectly, anyone can update them. As a side note, I would rather have a nonexistent faction be listed, than accidentally remove an existing faction that has merely downsized or changed websites.

Third, your first four points have nothing to do with what I wrote to you earlier. You didn't do anything about those problems either, when it is fully within your power to do so. Furthermore, I did not create those lists, nor do I maintain them in any other way that making sure that they follow a common format and that they are not vandalized.

Fourth, I didn't say that you couldn't show the whole link, I just said that I wanted the Guild Directory pages done in a standard way. Your edit where you unnecessarily added "Server:" to every listing was prior to your removing the brackets around the links, so that's why it and all following revisions got undone. If you think we should change it that way, then, as I stated earlier, I'm open to hearing your reasons why, I just don't see the difference. You say, "Why not?", but I asked "Why?" first. If your reason sounds good, then all Guild Directories should be changed the same way, and not just one of them.

Finally, there is no need to be insulting. It doesn't make what you say any more valid. If you have constructive criticism I'm more than happy to listen to that, but I won't waste my time listening to empty insults. -- Sangodoc - PWI wiki mod (talk) 22:39, 9 November 2010 (UTC)

(the above text on this indent level is a response to the first comment here)